14.5.22. What is the maximum energy that photons with energy $\mathcal{E} = 10 \text{ eV}$ can acquire when scattered on a counter-propagating electron beam with energy $\mathcal{E}_e = 10^{10} \text{ eV}$?
Solution
The problem can be solved simply by writing down the conservation of momentum and energy, but I want to show another method. One can notice that if we go to a reference frame where the electrons in the beam are at rest, we observe the Compton effect. The change in energy upon scattering of a photon in this case can be obtained from the well-known formula
$$\frac{1}{\nu'}-\frac{1}{\nu}=\frac{h}{m_e c^2}(1-\cos\alpha)$$ where $\alpha$ is the scattering angle of the photon. This formula is derived in problem $14.5.23$.
As a result, we need to carefully transform to such a system, calculate the energy, and then transform back to the laboratory frame.
For convenience, we switch to a system of units where $c = 1$. This simplifies the notation, and it is convenient that the photon momentum equals its energy. We will denote energies in the laboratory frame (LF) by $\mathcal{E}$, and in the electron rest frame (RF) by $E$.
Thus, the gamma factor for the electron in the LF is obviously $$\gamma=(1-v^2)^{-\frac{1}{2}}=\frac{ \mathcal{E}_e }{m_e}, \ \to \ v=\sqrt{1-\left(\frac{m_e}{ \mathcal{E}_e }\right)^2}=\frac{\sqrt{\mathcal{E}_e^2-m_e^2}}{\mathcal{E}_e}$$ This is the speed at which the RF moves relative to the LF. We find the photon energy in the RF using the relativistic Doppler effect: $$E=\mathcal{E}\gamma(1+v)$$
Using the Compton formula, we obtain the energy change upon collision: $$E'=\frac{Em_e}{E(1-\cos\alpha)+m_e}$$
The maximum energy in the LF is achieved when the photon is scattered backward in the RF ($\alpha = \pi$), because upon inverse transformation to the LF, a photon scattered backward in the RF receives the maximum Doppler shift forward (in the direction of the electron's motion): $$E'=\frac{Em_e}{2E+m_e}$$ Inverse transformation (taking into account that the photon's direction has reversed): $$\mathcal{E}'=E'\gamma(1+v)$$ $$\mathcal{E}'_{max} =\frac{Em_e}{2E+m_e}\gamma(1+v)=\frac{\mathcal{E}\gamma^2(1+v)^2m_e}{2\mathcal{E}\gamma(1+v)+m_e}$$ Multiply numerator and denominator by $(1 - v)$: $$\mathcal{E}'_{max} =\frac{\mathcal{E}m_e(1+v)}{2\mathcal{E}\gamma(1-v^2)+m_e(1-v)}$$ $$\mathcal{E}'_{max} =\frac{\mathcal{E}m_e(1+v)\gamma}{2\mathcal{E}+m_e\gamma(1-v)}$$ $$\mathcal{E}'_{max} =\mathcal{E}\frac{\mathcal{E}_e(1+v)}{2\mathcal{E}+\mathcal{E}_e(1-v)}$$ Finally substitute the velocity: $$\mathcal{E}'_{max} =\mathcal{E}\frac{\mathcal{E}_e+\sqrt{\mathcal{E}_e^2-m_e^2}}{2\mathcal{E}+\mathcal{E}_e-\sqrt{\mathcal{E}_e^2-m_e^2}}$$
Now return to standard units:
$$\mathcal{E}'_{max} =\mathcal{E}\frac{\mathcal{E}_e+\sqrt{\mathcal{E}_e^2-(m_e c^2)^2}}{2\mathcal{E}+\mathcal{E}_e-\sqrt{\mathcal{E}_e^2-(m_e c^2)^2}}$$ Don't forget the numerical value (Savchenko forgot...): $$\mathcal{E}_{max}\approx 6\cdot10^9 \ эВ$$ Note: Savchenko apparently has a small typo in the answer.