Statement
14.3.28∗. A charged capacitor suspended on a thread, it would seem, cannot move translationally together with the thread and the suspension, if the angle
Solution
Consider the capacitor in a reference frame relative to which it, together with the suspension, moves translationally with velocity
Let
When the charged capacitor is in motion, a magnetic field also appears. Therefore, the charges on each plate are acted upon not only by the electric force, but also by the magnetic part of the Lorentz force.
At first sight, the resultant force is not directed along the normal to the plate, which seems to imply that a torque should arise. We will show that this does not lead to any rotation of the capacitor.
Let
Since there is no magnetic field in the rest frame of the capacitor, in the moving frame the electric and magnetic fields are related by
The Lorentz force acting on a charge
Substituting the expression for the magnetic field, we obtain
Using the vector identity
we see that for the component of the field parallel to
For the transverse component,
Hence,
Thus,
Substituting the components of the electric field, we obtain
Therefore,
Thus, the resultant force is indeed not directed along the normal to the plate.
However, one cannot conclude from this that the acceleration is directed along the force. In relativistic mechanics, force is defined by
where
For the components of acceleration parallel and perpendicular to the velocity, the following relations hold:
Hence,
Consider the ratio of the acceleration components:
Therefore,
Substituting the previously found ratio of the force components,
But
Therefore,
Hence, the acceleration vector makes the same angle
In other words,
This can also be seen directly. From the expressions for the force components,
while for the transverse component,
Since
we obtain
Thus,
These two components correspond exactly to the decomposition of a vector directed along the normal to the plate.
For the opposite plate, the acceleration has the same magnitude and the opposite direction. Therefore, the electromagnetic interaction causes only mutual attraction of the plates along their common normal and does not produce any relative rotation.
If we use the angle
so that
Then
which again shows that the acceleration is directed perpendicular to the plate.
Therefore, although the resultant electromagnetic force in the moving frame is not directed along the normal to the plates, the relativistic relation between force and acceleration ensures that the acceleration itself is normal to the plates.
Hence, no rotation of the capacitor occurs.
This is also consistent with the principle of relativity: uniform translational motion of the capacitor together with the Earth cannot be detected by means of an internal mechanical experiment.
Answer
The resultant electromagnetic force in the moving frame is indeed deflected from the normal to the plate. However, in relativistic mechanics, force and acceleration need not be parallel.
From the relations
it follows that the acceleration components have precisely the ratio required for the acceleration vector to be directed along the normal to the plate.
Therefore,
Note: in the official answer, the angle
These corrections do not change the physical conclusion: the acceleration is directed perpendicular to the plate, and the capacitor does not rotate.